3 replies to this topic

[fmalik]

Hello,

 

I am sizing a vertical separators and there are multiple methods of sizing namely GPSA, Svercek Method etc. I was wondering which method is more accurate in terms of sizing from your experience to calculate the vertical height and diameter. 

 

thank you

[Bobby Strain]

You can find software at my site to easily size vertical separators. And compare the results to other methods. I don't recommend anything by Svercek.

 

Bobby

[breizh]

Hi,

A few documents to support your work.

Definitely GPSA is the right document.

This link is also a good reference:

BN-EG-UE109 Guide for Vessel Sizing (red-bag.com)

 

Good luck

Breizh

Attached Files

•  Gas_Liquid_Separation_Technology.pdf   2.95MB   17 downloads
•  Mesh Gas liquid separation.pdf   2.51MB   13 downloads
•  TWO Phase Separator Design Guide By Manish Shah.pdf   2.59MB   16 downloads

[shvet1]

I was wondering which method is more accurate in terms of sizing from your experience  

 

Accurate? What do you mean accurate? How separator ID may be accurate or inaccurate? Separator has two features only (1) it works as intended or not, (2) how much money you spent.

 

How much money you are ready to invest and which process cases this separator will unable to treat - this is the right choice of calculation method. It is an engineer's skill to define those conditions properly.

Edited by shvet1, 04 December 2023 - 12:12 AM.