6 replies to this topic

[poojabathula369@gmail.com]

Few Basic Engineering deliverables are:

Basis of Design

Process Design Criteria

Process Flow Diagrams (PFDs)

Process Description

Process Simulation

Heat and Material Balance

Piping & Instrument Diagrams (P & IDs)

Line List

Tie-in List

Equipment List

Equipment Process Datasheets

Instrument Datasheets

Operating, Control & Safeguarding Philosophy

Line Sizing & Hydraulic Report

Equipment Sizing Report

Material Selection Report

Utility Requirements

Chemical

Relief Valve Sizing and Dossier

Flare System and depressurization study

Shutdown Key

HAZID Review & HAZID Report

HAZOP / SIL Studies Participation

 

Few Detailed Engineering Deliverables include:

Design Basis 

Process Flow Diagram (PFD)

Heat & Mass Balance

Piping & Instrument Diagrams (P&IDs) 

Line List

Equipment List 

Final Line Sizing and Hydraulic Report

Operating, Control and Safeguarding Philosophy

Commissioning Procedure & Plan

Plant Operating Manual

 

My question is, basic engineering and detailed engineering have similar deliverables? Then what is the difference between those deliverables? What are the differences? What updates do we make to the deliverables in detailed engineering? Please explain in detail.

[Pilesar]

Detailed engineering is more detailed. Before detailed engineering, you might know the vessel size and the number of nozzles. Afterwards, you will know the location of each nozzle on the vessel and which direction it points. Before you might know the approximate line lengths and line sizes. Afterwards you will know the exact lengths of each pipe section and where the elbows are located. Filling in the details can lead to discovery of small changes needed to fit everything together for best operation and maintenance. Basic engineering is good enough for a reasonable cost estimate but not good enough to send construction crews to the field.

[fallah]

 

Few Basic Engineering deliverables are:

Basis of Design

Process Design Criteria

Process Flow Diagrams (PFDs)

Process Description

Process Simulation

Heat and Material Balance

Piping & Instrument Diagrams (P & IDs)

Line List

Tie-in List

Equipment List

Equipment Process Datasheets

Instrument Datasheets

Operating, Control & Safeguarding Philosophy

Line Sizing & Hydraulic Report

Equipment Sizing Report

Material Selection Report

Utility Requirements

Chemical

Relief Valve Sizing and Dossier

Flare System and depressurization study

Shutdown Key

HAZID Review & HAZID Report

HAZOP / SIL Studies Participation

 

Few Detailed Engineering Deliverables include:

Design Basis 

Process Flow Diagram (PFD)

Heat & Mass Balance

Piping & Instrument Diagrams (P&IDs) 

Line List

Equipment List 

Final Line Sizing and Hydraulic Report

Operating, Control and Safeguarding Philosophy

Commissioning Procedure & Plan

Plant Operating Manual

 

My question is, basic engineering and detailed engineering have similar deliverables? Then what is the difference between those deliverables? What are the differences? What updates do we make to the deliverables in detailed engineering? Please explain in detail.

 

 

Hi,

 

Please try to prepare a complete master document list of a project and you will see the differences you will want to know after reading...

[breizh]

Hi,

To support your work, take a look at this link:

Library (red-bag.com)

 

Get contact with someone knowledgeable in your organization, the best way to learn from experienced people.

 

Good luck

Breizh

[shvet1]

 

Then what is the difference between those deliverables? What are the differences?

 

 

The difference is Final Investment Decision (FID). BD is provided for Feasibility Study and/or Front-End Engineering Design before FID is made. DD is provided to execute the Investment Plan as a result of FID.

[latexman]

At the end of Basic Engineering, the capital estimate is believed to be about +/- 25% accuracy.

 

At the end of Detailed Engineering, the capital estimate is believed to be about +/- 10% accuracy.

 

Operating cost estimates undergo improved accuracy also going from Basic to Detailed Engineering.

 

Making a good business decision requires accurate capital and operating cost estimates.  

[breizh]

Hi,
Under project engineering you will find some relevant/general information about project
Sugar Engineers (sugartech.co.za)
Good luck
Breizh